Skip to Content

Lake Arthur, Pennsylvania Fishing

Location and Fishing Information: Lake Arthur is located in Butler County, Pennsylvania and is also the Gem of Moraine National Forest. The lake is known for its beauty and has a 20 HP limit. The lake covers just over 3,200 acres of surface area and is home to many events throughout the year.

Popular Fishing Species List

There are numerous different species of fish to find on this body of water. So, what type of fish are in this lake? You can find White Crappie, Black Crappie,Channel Catfish, Flathead Catfish, Muskie, Tiger Muskie, Yellow Perch, Bluegill, Rainbow Trout, Lake Trout, Brown Trout, Smallmouth Bass, Walleye and Largemouth Bass on these waters.

Top Species and Creel Limits

  • Crappie: No Minimum- 50 combined species total
  • Yellow Perch: No Minimum- 50 combined species total
  • Sunfish: No Minimum- 50 combined species total
  • Channel Catfish: No Minimum- 50 combined species total
  • Muskie: Open year-round with a 40 inch minimum and can keep 1
  • Walleye: Jan 1- March 14 / May 2 – Dec 31 15 inch minimum – limit 6
  • White Bass: See PA Summary Book
  • Largemouth Bass: See PA Summary Book
  • Smallmouth Bass: See PA Summary Book

Lake Arthur Fishing Videos

Marinas on this lake

  • Marina Name: Davis Hollow Marina
  • Address: N Shore Dr, Portersville, PA 16051
  • Phone Number: (724) 368-9346
  • HP limit: 20 HP Limit
  • Marina Name: Watts Bay Marina
  • Address: N Shore Dr, Portersville, PA 16051
  • Phone Number: (717) 787-2869
  • HP limit: 20 HP Limit
  • Amenities: Camping, Boat Rentals, Boat Ramp